Snow Stops and Heating Coils: Do You Need Them on Your Home?

Every winter in Simcoe County and Muskoka, homeowners ask us the same two questions. Should I put snow stops on my roof? Should I run heating coils in my eavestroughs? They’re fair questions. A slab of snow sliding off the roof or a row of icicles hanging over the front step is no joke. Here’s an honest look at both, and why we don’t like to install either one.

What are snow stops?

Snow stops (also called snow guards) are small brackets or bars fastened to the roof, usually near the eaves. They hold the snow in place so it melts off slowly instead of sliding off all at once. You see them most often on metal roofs, where snow can slide off quickly.

Pros

  • They protect people, pets and cars below from sudden “roof avalanches.”

  • They help keep sliding snow from tearing off eavestroughs, crushing shrubs or blocking doors.

  • They’re useful over entrances, decks and walkways.

Cons

  • Every snow stop is fastened through the roof, and each fastener is a possible leak.

  • Adding them after the fact can affect your roof warranty, depending on the manufacturer.

  • Holding snow on the roof adds weight and keeps it there longer. On a poorly ventilated roof, that can mean more melting and refreezing at the eaves.

Why we don’t like to install them

Snow stops are roofing work. They’re fastened into the roof itself, and at Performance Exteriors, we aren’t roofing professionals. The leak and warranty risks are real, so this job belongs with a qualified roofer who can install snow stops correctly and stand behind the roof. If you need them, we’re happy to point you in the right direction.

What about heating coils?

Heating coils (heat cables) are electric cables clipped along the roof edge or run through eavestroughs and downspouts. The idea is to melt a channel so water can drain instead of freezing into ice dams and icicles.

Pros

  • They can keep water moving in a known trouble spot.

  • They can be a short-term fix while you plan a permanent repair.

Cons

  • They treat the symptom, not the cause. The ice is still forming. You’re just melting a path through it.

  • They add to your hydro bill every winter they run.

  • Clips and cables can damage shingles and eavestroughs, and cables wear out over time.

  • If the cable is off or fails during a cold snap, the ice comes right back.

  • Poorly installed or low-quality cables can be a safety risk.

Why we don’t recommend them

There are very few homes where heating coils are the best answer. In most cases, ice dams are a sign of what’s happening in your attic, not a problem with your eavestroughs.

Heat escapes from the house into the attic and warms the roof deck. The snow melts and runs down to the cold edge of the roof, then freezes again. That ice builds up into a dam, and the water behind it can back up under the shingles.

The lasting fix is to keep the roof cold:

  • Proper attic insulation keeps household heat where it belongs, in your living space.

  • Good ventilation moves cold outside air through the attic. It comes in through the soffit vents at the eaves and leaves at the roof peak. Blocked or missing soffit venting is one of the most common problems we find.

  • Air sealing around attic hatches, pot lights and vents stops warm air from leaking up.

Get those right and most ice dam problems go away on their own, with no cables, no hydro bill and no holes in your roof.

The bottom line

Snow stops have their place, but they’re a roofing job, so call a roofer. Heating coils rarely solve the real problem. If you’re fighting ice dams or icicles every winter, start with your insulation and ventilation. Then make sure your soffit, fascia and eavestroughs are in good shape and doing their job.

Not sure what’s causing the ice on your home? Contact Performance Exteriors for a free assessment. We’ll look at your soffit venting and eavestroughs and give you a straight answer.

Next
Next

Eavestroughs Torn Down by Snow or Wind? What to Do First