Where to Buy Gutter Guards: DIY vs Professional Install

Short answer:

You can buy gutter guards at most hardware stores and put them in yourself in an afternoon.

But the ones that hold up to pine needles, heavy snow, and freeze-thaw winters usually aren't sitting on a store shelf.

They're installed by a pro, and they're built into the eavestrough instead of just dropped on top of it.

Here's the difference, and how to decide which one makes sense for your home.

Where can you buy gutter guards?

If you want to do it yourself, the big-box hardware and home stores carry them.

If you want a system that's built to last, you usually get it through an eavestrough installer.

Many of the heavier-duty systems are sold mainly through trained installers, because they only work properly when they're fitted and fastened the right way.

So the real question isn't where to buy them.

It's which kind will actually work on your house.

The main types of gutter guards

Most gutter guards fall into one of five types.

  • Foam inserts. A foam wedge sits inside the eavestrough. Up here, pine needles and seeds stick to the top, and the foam holds water that can freeze.

  • Brush guards. A big bottle-brush lies in the trough. Needles and leaves get tangled in the bristles, and you have to pull it out to clean it.

  • Snap-in screens. A plastic or metal screen clips over the top. Needles poke through the holes, and screens can lift or pop off under snow and ice.

  • Surface-tension (hood) covers. Water curls over a rounded lip into the trough. Heavy rain can shoot past the lip, and ice can form on the curve.

  • Micro-mesh with a continuous hanger. A fine mesh filters water, and a hanger runs the full length of the eavestrough. It costs more, and it needs a proper professional install.

The first three are the ones you'll usually find on the shelf.

The last one is what we install.

What goes wrong with DIY gutter guards up here

Store-bought guards are designed to work almost anywhere.

Simcoe County, Muskoka, and Georgian Bay aren't almost anywhere.

Here's what we see most often:

  • Pine needles. We're surrounded by white pine, and needles slip right through most screens. Once they're inside, they're harder to clean out than they were before.

  • Snow and ice weight. A heavy, wet snow load sits on the guard and the eavestrough together. Clip-on guards can bend, pop loose, or pull the trough away from the house.

  • Freeze-thaw. Anything that holds water, like foam or packed debris, freezes solid. Then meltwater has nowhere to go and spills over the edge, right next to your foundation.

  • The eavestrough itself. A guard can't fix a trough that's sagging, pitched the wrong way, or pulling off rotten fascia. Putting a new guard on a tired system just hides the problem.

  • Ladder work. Installing guards means a lot of time on a ladder, often in fall, when it's wet and cold.

None of this means DIY guards never work.

It means they're often the wrong fit for a house surrounded by pines with a real Canadian winter.

What a professional install includes

We install the Alu-Rex DoublePro system, a micro-filter guard built into a continuous hanger.

Instead of clips spaced every couple of feet, the hanger supports your eavestrough along its entire length.

Alu-Rex rates it to hold up to 425 lb per linear foot, and it's made to keep out pine needles, seeds, and leaves.

On a Performance Exteriors install, we also:

  1. Check the fascia behind your eavestroughs before we quote, so there are no surprises halfway through.

  2. Check the pitch, so water actually runs to the downspouts.

  3. Install it to the manufacturer's specifications, so the warranty isn't voided.

  4. Direct your downspouts away from the foundation.

  5. Clean up and haul away the old material.

We can add gutter guards to your existing eavestroughs if they're in good shape, or install them with new seamless eavestroughs.

When you pair them with a new eavestrough install from us, we offer an extended warranty.

What does it cost?

A professional system costs more up front than a box of store-bought screens.

The price depends on:

  • How many feet of eavestrough you have

  • How many storeys up the work is

  • Whether your existing eavestroughs can stay, or need replacing

  • Whether any fascia behind them needs repair first

Because every home is different, we don't list a set price. A number without seeing your home would just be a guess.

The best way to get a real number for your home is a free estimate. We'll look at what you have and tell you honestly whether guards are worth it for your house.

DIY or professional: which one is right for you?

DIY from the store

  • Up-front cost: Lower

  • Pine needles: Usually slip through

  • Snow and ice: Often lifts, bends, or pops off

  • Supports the eavestrough: No

  • Your time on a ladder: All of it

  • Warranty: Product only, if installed correctly

Professional install

  • Up-front cost: Higher

  • Pine needles: Kept out by micro-filter systems

  • Snow and ice: Built into the eavestrough

  • Supports the eavestrough: Yes, with a continuous hanger

  • Your time on a ladder: None

  • Warranty: Product plus workmanship

DIY can make sense if: you have a one-storey home, mostly leafy trees (not pines), eavestroughs in good shape, and you're comfortable on a ladder.

A professional system makes more sense if: you have pines nearby, a two-storey home or a cottage, eavestroughs that overflow or sag, or you're simply done cleaning them out every fall.

Quick recap

  • You can buy basic gutter guards at the hardware store, but most aren't built for pine needles or heavy snow.

  • Foam, brush, and snap-in screens are the easiest to install and the first to fail up here.

  • A micro-filter guard with a continuous hanger keeps debris out and strengthens the eavestrough at the same time.

  • A guard is only as good as the eavestrough and fascia under it.

Not sure which one your home needs?

We serve Simcoe County, Muskoka, Georgian Bay, Barrie, and Orillia.

Reserve Your Free Estimate at performanceexteriors.ca or call 705-238-2441.

Previous
Previous

Eavestroughs Torn Down by Snow or Wind? What to Do First

Next
Next

What Is a Soffit on a House?